Programming Styles

Over the years, I have met software developers of all levels who possess an assortment of programming styles.  Some were good, others not so.

I’ve decided to compile a list of the more eccentric and exotic programming styles in this article.

25% Off CouponSee if any of your fellow programming colleagues falls into any of these categories.

Shotgun Programming

It is a programming style where the developer tries random shots at the code. “Well, this method call is failing…. I’ll try changing this parameter from false to true!” Then of course it doesn’t work and the developer goes: “Well, maybe I could just comment out the whole method call!” and so on. It can go on forever until it works by pure chance or the developer is rescued by a peer who points the correct solution.

A regular developer can go crazy in a few hours if he finds himself pairing with a shotgun programmer. It can drive you NUTS. Two shotgun programmers should never do pair programming together, because their destructive results are magnified when they work together.

Programming By Accident

It is a mild form of Shotgun Programming, and it is surprising to see how common it is. I think this category encompasses the majority of developers worldwide by a wide margin. It happens when the developers doesn’t really understand what he is doing, but things work. The dev codes some more, and the program still works. Since this is happening by accident, at some point something will break and the dev will have no idea on how to fix it. At this point, he usually has 2 courses of action: stop and understand what he did, in order to find the cause of the error, or, most likely, engage into Shotgun Programming to try to fix the problem.

Test Driven Development came to the rescue of the millions of programmers by accident. Now, you have an excuse to be program by accident: as long as the tests pass, you are good. Don’t get me wrong, Test Driven Development is a Good Thing, and it limits the damage that can be caused by Programming by Accident.

Cargo-Cult Programming

The term comes from the Cargo Cults that appeared in many pacific islands during World War II. During the war, the US used the islands as bases and built airstrips for their cargo planes. The natives were amazed by the planes who brought all those goods and food. When the war was over, the planes disappeared, and the natives built their own air strips, with bamboo control towers, in the hope that if they did exactly like the white men did, the planes would return and bring back the beloved cargo.

Cargo cult programming is the practice of applying a popular solution just because everybody else is doing and it seems to work form them, but without understanding why it is being done that way. Lots of people engaged on it during the first years of J2EE by overusing EJBs and Entity Beans, for example.

Least Effort Programming

This style is very common specially among junior developers. One day you are assigned a task to fix a NullPointerException, so you just go to the line of code where the exception is generated and surrounds it with a if (reference != null).

It may very well work but you didn’t solve the cause of the bug, you just hid it until it comes back to haunt you again. What you should have done is to go back and fix the problem that caused the reference to be null in the first place.

Design Pattern Driven Programming

As the name says, it is the programming style where you use design patterns for EVERYTHING. Your code is full of Facade this, Observer that, Strategy whatever, Adapter, blah blah blah. It reaches a point where you have to dig real deep to find the code that does the actual job in the middle of the Design Pattern Tangle.

Surgical Programmer

When working on a bug, the Surgical Programmer investigates the cause. And then the cause’s cause. Then, he investigates the consequences of changing the code that is causing the other code to cause the other code to fail. Then he does a text search to find all usages of that class in the code, just in case. And for each match, he does another text search to find what uses the usage’s usage. Then he writes unit tests for 30 different possible scenarios, even those that don’t have anything to do with the bug he is fixing. In the end, full of confidence and with surgical precision, he fixes a typo.

In the meantime, the regular programmer fixed five other bugs.

Butcher Programmer

It is the programmer that has an extreme itch to refactor everything he touches. It is the kind of programmer that, the night before shipping, when fixing a typo in an error message, changes 10 classes, refactors other 20, plus changes the build script and 5 deployment descriptors.  Products that are worked on by Butcher programmers never get released!  Avoid hiring these types of programmers at all costs.

Advertisements
Published in: on January 17, 2010 at 10:28 pm  Comments (6)  

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: https://blackbeltreview.wordpress.com/2010/01/17/programmingstyles/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

6 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. I am a butcher and surgical. 😦 That must really suck. Thanks for the post!

  2. I’m a Least_Effort/Shotgun Programmer combo. And towards the end of a project, I can become the Butcher.

  3. LoL!!!
    Excellent Analysis.Do you think JavaScript based design patterns must be the outcome of Design pattern driven programming!!!

    • Very likely. But thanks to many popular JavaScript frameworks (such as jQuery), a lot of the headaches are lessened.

  4. […] developers start off reading books looking for best practices, eager to become a Good Developer. However, after a while, when you have realized that you’re not gonna make it to be the next […]

  5. […] developers start off reading books looking for best practices, eager to become a Good Developer. However, after a while, when you have realized that you’re not gonna make it to be the next […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: